Florida Housing Finance Corporation
Credit Underwriting Report
RIVERVIEW6
Competitive 9%
Housing Credits (“HC”) and Invitation to
Participate (“ITP”) 2022 Construction Housing Inflation Response
Program (“CHIRP”)
RFA 2020-201 / 2021-111C
H
ousing Credit Financing for Affordable Housing Developments Located in
Medium and Small Counties
S
ection A: Report Summary
S
ection B: Housing Credit Allocation Recommendation & Contingencies
S
ection C: Supporting Information & Schedules
P
repared by
First Housing Development Corporation of Florida
FINAL REPORT
October 31, 2022
Exhibit E
Page 1 of 43
RIVERVIEW6
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Section A
Report Summary
Recommendation
A1-A9
Overview
A10-A14
Uses of Funds
A15-A21
Operating Pro Forma
A22-A24
Section B
Housing Credit Allocation Recommendation & Contingencies
B1
Section C
Supporting Information & Schedules
Additional Development & Third Party Information
C1-C9
Applicant Information
C10-C14
Syndication Information
C15
General Contractor Information
C16-C17
Property Management Information
C18-C19
Exhibits
15 Year Pro Forma
1
Housing Credit Allocation Calculation
Description of Features and Amenities
2. 1-4
3. 1-6
Completion and Issues Checklist
4. 1-2
Exhibit E
Page 2 of 43
Section A
Report Summary
Exhibit E
Page 3 of 43
Recommendation
HTG RIVERVIEW6, LTD. ("Applicant") has applied for a Federal 9% HC determination to
finance the new construction of RIVERVIEW6 (“Development”). First Housing Development
Corporation of Florida (“FHDC”, “First Housing”, or Servicer”) recommends an annual 9% HC
Allocation of $1,699,990 and an annual allocation of HC CHIRP in the amount of $500,000, for
an overall annual HC allocation of $2,199,990 be awarded to finance the new construction
Development.
Development Name:
RFA/Program Numbers: /
Address:
City: Zip Code: County: County Size:
Development Category: Development Type:
Construction Type:
Demographic Commitment:
Primary: of the Units
Unit Composition:
# of ELI Units: ELI Units Are Restricted to AMI, or less. Total # of units with PBRA?
# of Link Units: Are the Link Units Demographically Restricted? # of NHTF Units:
6
Yes
0
12
30%
0
New Construction
Mid-Rise (5-6 Stories)
Masonry
Family
for
100%
901 6th Avenue West
Bradenton
34205
Manatee
Medium
DEVELOPMENT & SET-ASIDES
RIVERVIEW6
RFA 2020-201
2021-111C
Manatee County, North Port-Sarasota-Bradenton MSA
1,005,924$
80
66,016
3
2.0
7
1,093
60%
$139
1,432$
1,432$
1,246$
1,246$
1,246$
2
2.0
22
$1,571
1,208$
1,208$
3
2.0
7
1,093
70%
$1,347
$139
1,208$
1,208$
3
2.0
2
1,093
30%
$673
$139
534$
534$
534$
1,432$
120,288$
534$
12,816$
101,472$
1,432$
803
70%
$1,359
$1,165
469$
469$
39,396$
$113
469$
469$
1,052$
239,856$
$113
1,052$
1,052$
1,052$
328,944$
$113
1,246$
2
2.0
19
803
60%
$582
2
2.0
7
803
30%
1,032$
1,032$
1,032$
1,032$
86,688$
62,640$
1
1.0
7
624
70%
$1,134
$102
$102
870$
870$
870$
870$
384$
13,824$
1
1.0
6
624
60%
$972
$486
$102
384$
384$
384$
1
1.0
3
624
30%
High
HOME
Rents
Gross HC
Rent
Bed
Rooms
Bath
Rooms
Units
Square
Feet
AMI%
Low
HOME
Rents
Appraiser
Rents
CU Rents
Annual Rental
Income
Utility
Allow.
Net
Restricted
Rents
PBRA
Contr
Rents
Applicant
Rents
The Applicant selected Average Income Test; therefore, the Applicant must set-aside 15% of the
total units (12 units) as ELI Set-Aside units at 30% or less of Area Median Income (“AMI”). The
Exhibit E
Page 4 of 43
proposed Development must set aside 50% of the ELI Set-Aside units (6 units) as Link units for
Persons with Special Needs. In order to meet the commitment to set aside ELI units as Link units
for Persons with Special Needs, the Applicant must develop and execute a Memorandum of
Understanding (“MOU”) with at least one designated Special Needs Household Referral Agency
that provides supportive services for Persons with Special Needs for the county where the proposed
Development will be located (Manatee County). The MOU was approved by Florida Housing
Finance Corporation (“Florida Housing” or “FHFC”) on September 9, 2021.
The Tenant Selection Plan was approved by FHFC on April 28, 2022.
Buildings: Residential - Non-Residential -
Parking: Parking Spaces - Accessible Spaces -
Set Asides:
Absorption Rate:
units per month for
months.
Occupancy Rate at Stabilization: Physical Occupancy Economic Occupancy
Occupancy Comments
DDA: QCT: Multi-Phase Boost: QAP Boost:
Site Acreage: Density: Flood Zone Designation:
Zoning: Flood Insurance Required?:
1.402
57.06
X
T5, Urban Center
No
96.00%
95.00%
N/A - New Construction
No
Yes
No
Yes
30
2.7
Housing Credits
40.0%
32
60%
50
Housing Credits
45.0%
36
70%
50
Program
% of Units
# of Units
% AMI
Term (Years)
Housing Credits
15.0%
12
30%
50
1
0
99
4
Appraiser:
Integra Real ty Res ources - Orl ando ("Integra")
Architect:
Fl ux Archi tects , LLC | Eddi e Seymour
Market Study Provider:
Meridian Appraisal Group, Inc. ("Meridian")
Syndicator:
RJAHI
General Contractor 1:
Hennessy Construction Services Corp. ("Hennessy")
Management Company:
HTG Ma nagement, LLC ("HTG Ma nagement")
Devel oper:
HTG RIVERVIEW6 DEVELOPER, LLC
Li mited Partner
Raymond James Affordable Housing Investments, Inc. ("RJAHI")
99.9900%
Applicant/Borrower:
HTG RIVERVIEW6, LTD.
% Ownership
General Pa rtner
HTG RIVERVI EW6 GP, LLC
0.0100%
DEVELOPMENT TEAM
Exhibit E
Page 5 of 43
Credit Underwriter:
Date of Final CUR:
TDC PU Limitation at Application: TD
C PU Limitation at Credit Underwriting:
Minimum 1st Mortgage per Rule: Amount Dev. Fee Reduced for TDC Limit:
10/31/2022
$292,100
$437,239
$6,702,139
$0
First Housing
TOTAL
$33,857,873
$33,857,873
$423,223
HC Equity
RJAHI
$6,137,358
$20,457,861
$255,723
Deferred Developer Fee
HTG RIVERVIEW6 DEVELOPER,
LLC
$3,108,012
$3,108,012
$38,850
Local Government
Manatee County
$1,400,000
$1,400,000
$17,500
Local Government
City of Bradenton CRA
$1,300,000
$1,300,000
$16,250
Regulated Mortgage
Lender
Fifth Third Bank / Grandbridge/
Freddie Mac
$21,452,503
$7,132,000
$89,150
Local Government
City of Bradenton
$460,000
$460,000
$5,750
CONSTRUCTION/PERMANENT SOURCES:
Source
Lender
Construction
Permanent
Perm Loan/Unit
HC Annual Allocation - Initial Award
$1,699,990
HC Annual Allocation - Qualified in CUR
$2,199,990
HC Annual Allocation - Equity Letter of Interest
$2,199,990
Year 15 Pro Forma Expense Escalation Rate
3.00%
Housing Credit (HC) Syndication Price
$0.93
Proj ected Net Operati ng Income (NOI) - Year 1
$608,219
Proj ected Net Operati ng Income (NOI) - 15 Yea r
$716,018
Year 15 Pro Forma Income Escalation Rate
2.00%
Market Rent/Market Financing Stabilized Value
$25,700,000
Rent Restricted Market Financing Stabilized Value
$13,200,000
Deferred Devel oper Fee
$3,108,012
As-Is Land Value
$2,040,000
# of Months covered
by the Res erves
2.7
Operating Deficit &
Debt Servi ce Reserves
$253,068
Debt Servi ce
Coverage
1.13
1.11
1.07
1.07
1.07
Loan to Cost -
Cumulative
21%
22%
27%
30%
30%
Res tri cted Market
Financing LTV
54%
58%
68%
78%
78%
Ma rket Rate/Market
Financing LTV
28%
30%
35%
40%
40%
Amortizati on
40
0
0
0
-
Loan Term
15
15
18
15
-
Underwri tten Interes t
Rate
7.09%
1.75%
1.75%
0.00%
0.00%
Amount
$7,132,000
$460,000
$1,400,000
$1,300,000
$ -
Lender/Grantor
Grandbridge
Real Estate
Ca
pital LLC
("Grandbridge")
/ Freddie Mac
City of
Bradenton
Manatee
County
City of
Bradenton
Co
mmunity
Redevelopment
Agency ("CRA")
Lender
Lien Position
First
Second
Third
Fourth
Fifth
PERMANENT FINANCING INFORMATION
1st Source
2nd Source
3rd Source
4th Source
5th Source
Other
Exhibit E
Page 6 of 43
Changes from the Application:
COMPARISON CRITERIA
YES
NO
Does the level of experience of the current team equal or exceed that of the team
described in the application?
1-2.
Are all funding sources the same as shown in the Application?
3-4.
Are all local government recommendations/contributions still in place at the
level described in the Application?
X
Is the Development feasible with all amenities/features listed in the Application?
X
Do the site plans/architectural drawings account for all amenities/features listed
in the Application?
X
Does the applicant have site control at or above the level indicated in the
Application?
X
Does the applicant have adequate zoning as indicated in the Application?
X
Has the Development been evaluated for feasibility using the total length of set-
aside committed to in the Application?
X
Have the Development costs remained equal to or less than those listed in the
Application?
5.
Is the Development feasible using the set-asides committed to in the
Application?
X
If the Development has committed to serve a special target group (e.g. elderly,
large family, etc.), do the development and operating plans contain specific
provisions for implementation?
X
HOME ONLY: If points were given for match funds, is the match percentage
the same as or greater than that indicated in the Application?
N/A
HC ONLY: Is the rate of syndication the same as or greater than that shown in
the Application?
6.
Is the Development in all other material respects the same as presented in the
Application?
7-
11.
The following are explanations of each item checked "No" in the table above:
1. Since the Application, the Developer’s organizational structure has changed. Please see
Waiver Requests/Special Conditions for further information.
Developer Ownership (From):
Developer Ownership (To):
HTG RIVERVIEW6 DEVELOPER, LLC
Matthew A. Rieger – Manager
HTG Affordable Holdings, LLC - Sole Member
HTG RIVERVIEW6 DEVELOPER, LLC
Matthew A. Rieger – Manager
HTG Florida Developer, LLCSole Member
Exhibit E
Page 7 of 43
2. The General Partner, HTG RIVERVIEW6 GP, LLC is comprised of one Member, HTG
Affordable Holdings, LLC and one Manager, Mathew Rieger. Since the Application, the
ownership interests in HTG Affordable Holdings, LLC has changed and was approved by
FHFC’s staff on July 1, 2022.
Ownership (From):
Ownership (To):
HTG Affordable Holdings, LLC
Matthew A. Rieger Manager
Matthew A. Rieger Investment Trust 40%
Mathew A. Rieger Irrevocable MGM Trust 10%
Gina Rieger Irrevocable MGM Trust 10%
Meredith Branciforte Irrevocable MGM Trust 10%
Alexandra B. Balogh Trust 15%
Andrew C. Balogh Trust 15%
HTG Affordable Holdings, LLC
Matthew A. Rieger Manager
Matthew A. Rieger Investment Trust 50%
Mathew A. Rieger Irrevocable MGM Trust 8.3334%
Gina Rieger Irrevocable MGM Trust 8.3333%
Meredith Branciforte Irrevocable MGM Trust 8.3333%
Alexandra B. Balogh Trust 12.5%
Andrew C. Balogh Trust 12.5%
3. The Application indicated JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. would be providing the
construction and permanent financing; however, Fifth Third Bank will be providing the
construction financing and Grandbridge will be providing the permanent financing. In
addition, the construction loan amount has increased from $14,400,000 to an amount up to
$23,500,000; however, to balance source and uses First Housing anticipates a construction
loan in the amount of $21,452,503. The permanent loan amount has increased from
$5,200,000 to $7,132,000.
4. Since the Application, additional sources have been included, a loan from Manatee County
in the amount of $1,400,000 and a Bradenton CRA forgivable loan in the amount of
$1,300,000.
5. The Total Development Costs (“TDC”) have increased by a total of $11,268,737 or 49.89%
from $22,589,136 to $33,857,873 since the Application. The increase is mainly due to the
increase in construction costs.
6. Since the Application, the HC syndication rate has decreased from $0.94 to $0.93 and the
Syndicator name has changed from Raymond James Tax Credit Funds (“RJTCF”) to
RJAHI.
7. Since the Application, the unit mix has changed, which was approved by FHFC’s staff on
August 31, 2021.
Unit Mix (From)
Unit Mix (To)
(20) 1 Bed/1 Bath – 3 ELI Units
(40) 2 Bed/2 Bath – 6 ELI Units
(20) 3 Bed/2 Bath – 3 ELI Units
80 Total Units
(16) 1 Bed/1 Bath – 3 ELI Units
(48) 2 Bed/2 Bath – 7 ELI Units
(16) 3 Bed/2 Bath – 2 ELI Units
80 Total Units
Exhibit E
Page 8 of 43
8. Since the Application, the legal description has changed and was approved by FHFC’s staff
on August 31, 2021.
9. The Application indicated the Development is the first phase of a multiphase development.
However, according to the 21-Day Items, the Applicant no longer wishes to identify the
Development as a first phase of a multiphase development.
10. The 21-Day Requirements identified HTG Hennessy, LLC as the General Contractor
(“GC”); however, the GC is now Hennessy Construction Services Corp. First Housing
received the Florida Housing Finance Corporations General Contractor Certification form
for Hennessy Construction Services Corp., along with the experience chart.
11. At Application the address was 8th Street W, 8th Street W and 7th Avenue W intersection,
Bradenton. The address is 901 6
th
Avenue West, Bradenton, FL 34205.
The above changes have no substantial material impact to the HC recommendation for this
Development.
Does the Development Team have any FHFC Financed Developments on the Past
Due/Noncompliance Report?
According to the FHFC Asset Management Noncompliance Report, dated June 9, 2020, the
Development Team has the following noncompliance item(s) not in the correction period:
None
According to the FHFC Past Due report, dated September 22, 2022, the Development Team has
the following past due item(s):
None
Strengths:
1. The Principals, Developer, General Contractor, and the Management Company are
experienced in affordable multifamily housing.
2. The Principals have sufficient experience and substantial financial resources to develop
and operate the proposed Development.
Exhibit E
Page 9 of 43
3. Meridian prepared a Market Study for the Development, dated July 27, 2021 (Report Date).
The research indicates there is sufficient demand in the market to support the Development.
Within the competitive market area (“CMA”), the weighted average occupancy rate for
like-kind, existing, stabilized properties was 97%.
4. According to the Market Study, the absorption comparables range from 9 to 133 units per
month, with an average of 47 units per month. Meridian has projected an average
absorption rate of 30 units per month for the Development.
Issues and Concerns:
None
Mitigating Factors:
None
Waiver/Special Conditions:
1. According to the RFA, the Corporation will review the limited partnership agreement or
limited liability company operating agreement language on reserves for compliance with
the RFA requirement. If the limited partnership agreement or limited liability company
operating agreement does not specifically state that the parties will comply with the
Corporation’s RFA requirements, the Corporation will require an amendment of the
agreement and will not issue IRS form(s) 8609 until the amendment is executed and
provided to the Corporation.
The RFA includes language restricting the disposition of any funds remaining in any
operating deficit reserve(s) after the term of the reserve’s original purpose has terminated
or is near termination. The RFA also requires the Corporation to review the limited
partnership agreement or limited liability company operating agreement language on
reserves for compliance with the RFA requirement. While Florida Housing will continue
to require the Applicant to adhere to all requirements in the RFA including the restrictions
on the disposition of any funds in an operating deficit reserve account, Florida Housing
will not monitor the limited partnership agreement or limited liability company operating
agreement language for compliance with these requirements, as this would require analysis
of a legal contract. This deviation in process was included as an Information Item in the
April 29, 2022 FHFC Board meeting.
2. First Housing reviewed a letter, dated February 1, 2022, requesting approval to change the
principals of HTG RIVERVIEW6 DEVELOPER, LLC. Per the RFA, The Principals of
each Developer identified in the Application, including all co-Developers, may be changed
Exhibit E
Page 10 of 43
only by written request of an Applicant to Corporation staff and approval of the Board after
the Applicant has been invited to enter credit underwriting. The request was approved at
the June 17, 2022 FHFC Board meeting.
Additional Information:
1. Based on the TDC per unit limitations in affect as of the April 1, 2022 Board Meeting,
FHFC has set the TDC for Request for Applications 2020-201, exclusive of land costs and
Operating Deficit Reserves (“ODR”), of $437,239 per unit for new construction, mid-rise
(5-6 story) Enhanced Structural Systems (“ESS”) Construction developments. The TDC
for the Development, exclusive of demolition, land costs and operating deficit reserves, is
$31,528,055 or $394,101 per unit, which is within the parameters.
2. FHDC has completed the required minimum first mortgage qualifying test and finds that
the proposed first mortgage amount of $7,132,000 exceeds the minimum requirement of
$6,702,139.
3. The Development will contain approximately 3,765 square feet of commercial space.
Exhibit E
Page 11 of 43
Recommendation:
First Housing recommends an annual 9% HC allocation of $1,699,990 and an annual allocation of
HC CHIRP in the amount of $500,000, for an overall annual HC allocation of $2,199,990 be
awarded to finance the Development.
This recommendation is based upon the assumptions detailed in the Report Summary (Section A)
and Supporting Information and Schedules (Section C). In addition, this recommendation is
subject to the Housing Credit Allocation Recommendation and Contingencies (Section B). This
recommendation is only valid for six months from the date of the report.
The United States is currently under a national emergency due to the spread of the virus known as
COVID-19. The extent of the virus’ impact to the overall economy is unknown. More specifically,
it is unknown as to the magnitude and timeframe the residential rental market (e.g. absorption
rates, vacancy rates, collection losses, appraised value, etc.) and the construction industry (e.g.
construction schedules, construction costs, subcontractors, insurance, etc.) will be impacted.
Recommendations made by First Housing in this report, in part, rely upon assumptions made by
third-party reports that are unable to predict the impacts of the virus.
The reader is cautioned to refer to these sections for complete information.
Prepared by: Reviewed by:
Stephanie Petty Ed Busansky
Senior Credit Underwriter Senior Vice President
Exhibit E
Page 12 of 43
Overview
Construction Financing Sources:
Construction Sources Lender Application Revised Applicant Underwriter
Construction
Interest Rate
Annual
Construction Debt
Service
Regulated Mortgage Lender Firfth Third Bank $14,400,000 $23,200,000 $21,452,503 7.49% $1,606,792
Local Government Subsidy City of Bradenton $460,000 $460,000 $460,000 0.00% $0
Local Government Subsidy Manatee County $0 $1,400,000 $1,400,000 0.00% $0
Local Government Subsidy City of Bradenton CRA $0 $1,300,000 $1,300,000 0.00% $0
HC Equity RJAHI $7,989,150 $4,091,572 $6,137,358 N/A N/A
Deferred Developer Fee HTG RIVERVIEW6 DEVELOPER, LLC $2,888,156 $3,349,039 $3,108,012 N/A N/A
Tota l $25,737,306 $33,800,611 $33,857,873 $1,606,792
First Mortgage:
First Housing received a Term Sheet, dated September 12, 2022, provided by Fifth Third Bank,
which indicates Fifth Third Bank will provide a construction loan in the amount up to $23,500,000.
First Housing has concluded to a construction loan in the amount of $21,452,503, in order to
balance sources and uses. The term of the construction loan will be up to thirty (30) months from
the closing date, with unpaid principal and interest due at maturity. Interest shall accrue on the
outstanding principal balance at a variable rate equal to the Term Secured Overnight Financing
Rate (“SOFR”) plus a spread of 2.50%, with a Term SOFR floor of 0.75%. The construction
interest rate is calculated based upon the SOFR rate of 3.49% (as of October 19, 2022), plus a
2.50% spread, and a 1.50% underwriting cushion, for an “all-in” interest rate of 7.49%.
City of Bradenton
First Housing received a letter, dated January 5, 2022, from the City of Bradenton for construction
and permanent financing in the amount of $460,000. The term of the loan is 17 years with an
interest rate of 1.75%. Annual interest rate-only payments shall commence on the second year
following construction completion and are subject to available cash flow. The annual interest rate
shall also commence to accrue on the second year following construction completion. Any unpaid
accrued interest shall be repaid at the end of the loan term. First Housing is estimating a
construction period of 2 years and a permanent period of 15 years.
Manatee County
First Housing received a letter, dated September 22, 2022, with the proposed terms and conditions
of a loan in the amount of $1,400,000 from Manatee County. A portion or all can be drawn during
construction in 2023 or after substantial completion in 2024. The interest rate will be fixed at the
date of execution of the loan documents based on the greater of i) 1.75%; or ii) half of the
Exhibit E
Page 13 of 43
Applicable Federal Rate (“AFR”) Mid-Term Annual Rate. No interest or capital shall accrue until
conversion and interest payments shall begin after conversion. The total term is 20 years, of which
2 years is for construction and 18 years is for permanent phase. Annual payments of interest only
if cash flow is available after payment of operating expenses and required debt service on the
senior mortgage loan. All remaining unpaid interest shall accrue and will be due in full at maturity
along with the principal balance. As of October 2022, the AFR Mid-Term Annual rate is 3.28%,
of which half is 1.64%; therefore, First Housing concluded to an interest rate of 1.75%.
Bradenton CRA
First Housing received a City of Bradenton, City Council Agenda Memorandum, dated July 20,
2022. The Memorandum included a draft Land Use Restriction Agreement (“LURA”) which
detailed the CRA loan in the amount of $1,300,000. The term of the loan is 15 years following the
issuance of the certificate of occupancy. The interest rate of the loan shall be 0% and shall be non-
amortizing. The initial disbursement of the loan will in the amount of $150,000 and shall be made
to the owner within 30 days following commencement of construction. The remainder of the loan
shall be disbursed within 30 days following the achievement of 90% construction completion. The
loan is forgivable at the sole discretion of the CRA.
Housing Credit Equity:
The Applicant applied to the ITP 2022 CHIRP for additional HC in order to assist the Development
with increases related to market inflation. As the Applicant has an active HC Award, the maximum
amount of the HC CHIRP funding allowable is $500,000. The amount of the HC CHIRP has been
sized to $500,000. Please note the equity letter from RJAHI includes the HC CHIRP of $500,000
in addition to the original requested annual HC amount of $1,699,990.
First Housing received a letter of intent (“LOI), dated September 8, 2022, which indicates that
RJAHI will attempt to effect a closing of an investment by a Fund sponsored by RJAHI and will
acquire 99.99% ownership interest in the Applicant. Based on the LOI, the annual HC allocation
is estimated to be in the amount of $2,199,990 and a syndication rate of $0.93 per dollar. RJAHI
anticipates a net capital contribution of $20,457,861 and has committed to make available 30.00%
or $6,137,358 of the total net equity during the construction period. An additional $14,320,503
will be available at stabilization and upon receipt of the Form 8609. The first installment, in the
amount of $3,068,679 or 15.00%, meets the FHFC requirement that 15% of the total equity must
be contributed at or prior to the closing.
Deferred Developer Fee:
To balance the sources and uses of funds during construction, the Developer is required to defer
$3,108,012 or approximately 71.36% of the total Developer Fee of $4,355,593.
Exhibit E
Page 14 of 43
Permanent Financing Sources:
Permanent Sources Lender Application Re
vised Applicant Underwriter Term Yrs. Amort. Yrs.
Interest
Rate
Annual Debt
Service
Regulated Mortgage Lender Grandbridge/Freddie Mac $5,200,000 $7,132,000 $7,132,000 15 40 7.09% $537,450
Local Government Subsidy City of Bradenton $460,000 $460,000 $460,000 15 0 1.75% $8,050
Local Government Subsidy Manatee County $0 $1,400,000 $1,400,000 18 0 1.75% $24,500
Local Government Subsidy City of Bradenton CRA $0 $1,300,000 $1,300,000 15 0 0.00% $0
HC Equity RJAHI $15,978,300 $20,457,861 $20,457,861 N/A N/A N/A N/A
Deferred Developer Fee HTG RIVERVIEW6 DEVELOPER, LLC $2,888,156 $3,050,750 $3,108,012 N/A N/A N/A N/A
Total $24,526,456 $33,800,611 $33,857,873 $570,000
First Mortgage:
First Housing received a Mortgage Loan Term Sheet from Grandbridge, dated July 11, 2022. The
permanent loan is in the maximum amount of $7,132,000, which is subject to: i) maximum 90%
loan-to-value ratio and a minimum 1.15 debt service coverage ratio; and ii) additional lender terms.
The term of the permanent loan is 15 years with a 40-year amortization schedule. The interest rate
will be fixed prior to or at closing and will be based on the 10-year U.S. Treasury, with a floor of
2.74%, plus a spread of 2.95%. For underwriting purposes, the interest is calculated based upon
the current 10 Year U.S. Treasury rate of 4.14% (as of October 19, 2022) and a spread of 2.95%,
for an all-in interest rate of 7.09%.
City of Bradenton
First Housing received a letter, dated January 5, 2022, from the City of Bradenton for construction
and permanent financing in the amount of $460,000. The term of the loan is 17 years with an
interest rate of 1.75%. Annual interest rate-only payments shall commence on the second year
following construction completion and are subject to available cash flow. The annual interest rate
shall also commence to accrue on the second year following construction completion. Any unpaid
accrued interest shall be repaid at the end of the loan term. First Housing is estimating a
construction period of 2 years and a permanent period of 15 years.
Manatee County
First Housing received a letter, dated September 22, 2022, with the proposed terms and conditions
of a loan in the amount of $1,400,000 from Manatee County. A portion or all can be drawn during
construction in 2023 or after substantial completion in 2024. The interest rate will be fixed at the
date of execution of the loan documents based on the greater of: i) 1.75%; or ii) half of AFR Mid-
Term Annual Rate. Interest payments shall begin after conversion. The total term is 20 years, of
which 2 years is for construction and 18 years is for permanent phase. Annual payments of interest
only if cash flow is available after payment of operating expenses and required debt service on the
Exhibit E
Page 15 of 43
senior mortgage loan. All remaining unpaid interest shall accrue and will be due in full at maturity
along with the principal balance. As of October 2022, the AFR Mid-Term Annual rate is 3.28%,
of which half is 1.64%; therefore, First Housing concluded to an interest rate of 1.75%.
Bradenton CRA
First Housing received a City of Bradenton, City Council Agenda Memorandum, dated July 20,
2022. The Memorandum included a draft LURA which detailed the CRA loan in the amount of
$1,300,000. The term of the loan is 15 years following the issuance of the certificate of occupancy.
The interest rate of the loan shall be 0% and shall be non-amortizing. The initial disbursement of
the loan will in the amount of $150,000 and shall be made to the owner within 30 days following
commencement of construction. The remainder of the loan shall be disbursed within 30 days
following the achievement of 90% construction completion. The loan is forgivable at the sole
discretion of the CRA.
Housing Credit Equity:
The Applicant applied to the ITP 2022 CHIRP for additional HC in order to assist the Development
with increases related to market inflation. As the Applicant has an active HC Award, the maximum
amount of the HC CHIRP funding allowable is $500,000. The amount of the HC CHIRP has been
sized to $500,000. Please note the equity letter from RJAHI includes the HC CHIRP of $500,000
in addition to the original requested annual HC amount of $1,699,990.
First Housing has reviewed an executed equity letter, dated September 8, 2022, indicating RJAHI
shall attempt to effect a closing of an investment by a Fund sponsored by RJAHI and will provide
HC equity as follows:
Exhibit E
Page 16 of 43
Syndication Contributions
Capital Contributions Amount Percentage of Total Wh
en Due
1st Installment $3,068,679 15.00%
Closing
2nd Installment $1,022,893 5.00%
Paid at 50% Construction
Completion
3rd Installment $2,045,786 10.00%
Paid at 98% Construction
Completion
4th Installment $14,320,503 70.00%
Paid at project stabilization
and receipt of 8609s
Tota l $20,457,861 100.00%
Annual Credit Per Syndication Agreement
$2,199,990
Calculated HC Exchange Rate
$0.93
Limited Partner Ownership Percentage
99.99%
Proceeds Available During Construction
$6,137,358
Deferred Developer Fee:
To balance the sources and uses of funds during the permanent period the Developer is required
to defer $3,108,012 or approximately 71.36% of the total Developer Fee of $4,355,593. This meets
the CHIRP Requirement that the Applicant must defer at least 30% of their Developer Fee.
Exhibit E
Page 17 of 43
Uses of Funds
CONSTRUCTION COSTS:
Applicant Costs
Revised
Applicant Costs
Underwriters
Total Costs - CUR
Cost Per Unit
HC Ineligible
Costs - CUR
Demolition
$50,000 $0 $50,000 $625 $50,000
New Rental Units
$11,923,570 $18,463,289 $16,483,124 $206,039 $392,376
Si te Work
$0 $0 $1,930,165 $24,127 $193,017
Constr. Contr. Costs subject to GC Fee
$11,973,570 $18,463,289 $18,463,289 $230,791 $635,392
General Conditions
$0 $1,107,797 $1,107,797 $13,847 $0
Overhea d
$0 $369,266 $369,266 $4,616 $0
Profit
$1,669,300 $553,899 $553,899 $6,924 $0
General Liability Insurance
$0 $118,165 $118,165 $1,477 $0
Payment and Performance Bonds
$0 $152,322 $152,322 $1,904 $0
Total Constructi on Contract/Costs
$13,642,870 $20,764,738 $20,764,738 $259,559 $635,392
Hard Cost Contingency
$679,643 $1,038,237 $1,038,236 $12,978 $0
FF&E paid outside Constr. Contr.
$100,000 $275,000 $275,000 $3,438 $0
Other: Si te Prepara ti on
$0 $20,000 $20,000 $250 $0
Other: Construction-offsi te
$50,000 $50,000 $625 $50,000
$14,422,513 $22,147,975 $22,147,974 $276,850 $685,392
Total Construction Costs:
Notes to the General Development Costs:
1. The Applicant has provided an executed construction contract, dated September 15, 2022.
The contract is a Standard Form of Agreement between HTG RIVERVIEW6, LTD.
(“Owner”) and Hennessy Construction Services (“Contractor”) where the basis of payment
is the Cost of Work Plus a fee with a Guaranteed Maximum Price (“GMP”) in the amount
of $20,764,738. The contract requires a substantial completion date no later than 425 days
from the date of commencement. A 10% retainage on the Cost of the Work completed will
be withheld per draw until 50% of the GMP, no retainage thereafter.
2. First Housing utilized the Schedule of Values (“SOV”) to break out the construction costs.
3. The Schedule of Values does not breakout the demolition costs as it is lumped within the
Site Work costs of $1,980,165. According to an email dated October 5, 2022, the Applicant
is estimating demolition costs at $50,000.
4. The ineligible cost of $392,376 includes an ineligible cost of $297,600 for the commercial
hard costs and the cost of purchasing washers/dryers. Since the Applicant will be renting
the washers/dryers to the residents, the estimated cost of $94,776 to purchase these
appliances is ineligible.
5. First Housing has estimated that 10% of the site work as ineligible.
6. The GC Fees are within the maximum 14% of hard costs allowed by Rule Chapter 67-48.
The GC Fee stated herein is for credit underwriting purposes only, and the final GC fee
Exhibit E
Page 18 of 43
will be determined pursuant to the final cost certification process as per Rule Chapter 67-
48.023, F.A.C.
7. The GC Contract includes $225,713 in Allowances, which is 1.09% of the GMP.
According to Global Realty Services Group (“GRS”), the allowances are within an
acceptable range for the scope of work indicated.
All ROW & Offsite Landscape & Irrigation
$6,280
Irrigation Well w/Power (Included in Landscaping
Number)
$16,500
Closeout ALTA Survey
$5,000
Furnish & Install Primary Conduit
$42,000
Fire Department BDA System (Raceways & Wiring)
$102,451
CCTV/Access Control
$40,122
Common Area Interior Millwork: Shelving, Slatwall,
& Decorative Items
$8,360
Common Area Window Coverings
$5,000
Total
$225,713
8. Hard Cost Contingency is within 5% of total construction costs, as allowed for new
construction developments by Rule Chapter 67-48.
Exhibit E
Page 19 of 43
GENERAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS:
Applicant Costs
Revised
Applicant Costs
Underwriters
Total Costs - CUR
Cost Per Unit
HC Ineligible
Costs - CUR
Accounting Fees
$40,000 $25,000 $25,000 $313 $6,250
Appraisal
$5,500 $7,000 $7,000 $88 $0
Archi tect's Fee - La nds ca pe
$0 $7,000 $7,000 $88 $0
Architect's Fee - Site/Building Design
$339,822 $348,200 $348,200 $4,353 $0
Archi tect's Fee - Supervi s i on
$57,250 $40,500 $40,500 $506 $0
Building Permits
$160,000 $100,000 $100,000 $1,250 $0
Builder's Risk Insurance
$119,236 $184,633 $184,633 $2,308 $0
Engi neeri ng Fees
$55,250 $84,250 $84,250 $1,053 $0
Environmental Report
$10,000 $14,800 $14,800 $185 $0
FHFC Admi nis trative Fees
$152,999 $197,999 $197,999 $2,475 $197,999
FHFC Application Fee
$3,000 $3,000 $3,000 $38 $3,000
FHFC Credit Underwriting Fee
$17,845 $17,845 $19,717 $246 $19,717
FHFC Compliance Fee
$212,332 $198,506 $223,041 $2,788 $223,041
Impact Fee
$450,000 $556,859 $556,859 $6,961 $0
Lender Inspection Fees / Const Admin
$90,000 $65,000 $65,000 $813 $0
Green Bui ldi ng Cert. (LEED, FGBC, NAHB)
$20,000 $25,000 $25,000 $313 $0
Insurance
$55,001 $64,000 $64,000 $800 $0
Lega l Fees - Organizati onal Costs
$200,000 $160,000 $160,000 $2,000 $48,000
Market Study
$5,000 $5,000 $5,500 $69 $5,500
Marketing and Advertising
$75,000 $71,000 $71,000 $888 $71,000
Plan and Cost Review Analysis
$0 $5,000 $5,000 $63 $0
Property Taxes
$92,000 $68,931 $68,931 $862 $0
Soil Test
$12,000 $17,200 $17,200 $215 $0
Survey
$25,000 $25,000 $25,000 $313 $0
Tenant Relocati on Cos ts
$122,291 $0 $0 $0 $0
Title Insurance and Recording Fees
$195,800 $118,303 $118,303 $1,479 $11,830
Utility Connection Fees
$0 $268,000 $268,000 $3,350 $0
Soft Cost Contingency
$125,766 $135,401 $137,496 $1,719 $0
Other: Organizational Costs
$0 $10,000 $10,000 $125 $0
Other: FHFC Proces si ng Fees
$0 $0 $35,000 $438 $35,000
$2,641,092 $2,823,427 $2,887,429 $36,093 $621,337
Total General Development Costs:
Notes to the General Development Costs:
1. General Development Costs are the Applicant's updated estimates, which appear
reasonable.
2. First Housing has utilized actual costs for the Market Study.
3. FHFC Compliance Fee of $223,041 is based on the compliance fee calculator spreadsheet
provided by FHFC.
4. The FHFC Administrative Fee is based on 9% of the recommended annual housing credit
allocation.
5. The FHFC Credit Underwriting Fee includes an original underwriting fee of $14,721 and
a HC CHIRP Underwriting Fee of $4,996.
Exhibit E
Page 20 of 43
6. The Applicant provided a Professional Services Proposal between Abney + Abney Green
Solutions and HTG RIVERVIEW6, LTD. The Agreement is for National Green Building
Standard (“NGBS”) Administration and Green Verification services.
7. Organizational Costs of $10,000 is reimbursement for all filling fees associated with the
creation of the entities involved in the transaction.
8. FHFC Processing Fees of $35,000 includes a NOC Extension Fee of $10,000, LPA
Extension Fee of $10,000, CUR Extension Fee of $5,000, 10% Extension Fee of $5,000,
and a Site Control Extension Fee of $5,000.
9. The Underwriter adjusted Soft Cost Contingency to be 5% of the General Development
Costs, less the contingency as allowed for new construction developments.
Applicant Costs
Revised
Applicant Costs
Underwriters
Total Costs - CUR
Cost Per Unit
HC Ineligible
Costs - CUR
Construction Loan Origination Fee
$144,000 $176,250 $117,500 $1,469 $0
Construction Loan Closing Costs
$28,800 $47,000 $47,000 $588 $0
Construction Loan Interest
$752,175 $1,767,092 $1,799,607 $22,495 $921,399
Permanent Loan Application Fee
$0 $0 $11,632 $145 $11,632
Permanent Loan Origination Fee
$52,000 $71,320 $71,320 $892 $71,320
Permanent Loan Closing Costs
$10,400 $10,000 $10,000 $125 $10,000
Other: Legal - Lender
$0 $55,000 $55,000 $688 $27,500
Other: Syndication Fees
$0 $25,000 $25,000 $313 $25,000
Other: Predevel opment Loan Interest
$0 $50,000 $50,000 $625 $50,000
$987,375 $2,201,662 $2,187,059 $27,338 $1,116,851
$18,050,980 $27,173,064 $27,222,462 $340,281 $2,423,580
FINANCIAL COSTS:
Total Financial Costs:
Dev. Costs before Acq., Dev. Fee & Reserves
Notes to the Financial Costs:
1. The Construction Loan Origination Fee is based on 0.50% of the construction loan in the
amount of $23,500,000.
2. The Construction Loan Interest of $1,799,607 is based an interest rate of 7.49% on a loan
amount of $21,452,503, an estimated 2 year term, and an average outstanding loan balance
of 56%.
3. The Permanent Loan Application Fee includes a Freddie Mac Application Fee equal to the
greater of $3,000 or 0.1% of the Loan amount and a Lender’s Processing Fee of $4,500.
Exhibit E
Page 21 of 43
4. The Permanent Loan Origination Fee is based on 1% of the permanent loan in the amount
of $7,132,000.
5. The Predevelopment Loan Interest is payable to RJAHI. First Housing received a Second
Amended and Restated Promissory Note, dated October 21, 2021, where HTG Riverview6,
Ltd. promises to pay to the order of RJAHI the principal sum of $1,000,000.
Applicant Costs
Revised
Applicant Costs
Underwriters
Total Costs - CUR
Cost Per Unit
HC Ineligible
Costs - CUR
$0 $0 $0 $
0 $0
NON-LAND ACQUISITION COSTS
Total Non-Land Acquisition Costs:
Notes to the Non-Land Acquisition Costs:
1. As this is new construction, there are no non-land acquisition costs.
Applicant Costs
Revised
Applicant Costs
Underwriters
Total Costs - CUR
Cost Per Unit
HC Ineligible
Costs - CUR
Devel oper Fee - Unapportioned
$2,888,156 $4,347,729 $4,355,593 $54,445 $0
$2,888,156 $4,347,729 $4,355,593 $54,445 $0
Total Other Development Costs:
DEVELOPER FEE ON NON-ACQUISTION COSTS
Notes to the Other Development Costs:
1. The recommended Developer Fee does not exceed 16% of total development cost before
Developer Fee and Operating Deficit Reserves as allowed by RFA 2020-201 and Rule
Chapter 67-48.
Applicant Costs
Revised
Applicant Costs
Underwriters
Total Costs - CUR
Cost Per Unit
HC Ineligible
Costs - CUR
Land
$1,650,000 $2,026,750 $2,026,750 $25,334 $2,026,750
$1,650,000 $2,026,750 $2,026,750 $25,334 $2,026,750
LAND ACQUISITION COSTS
Total Acquisition Costs:
Notes to Acquisition Costs:
1. First Housing received five Settlement Statements with a total purchase price of
$2,026,750.
i. First Housing received a Buyer’s and Seller’s Combined Closing Statement, dated
March 28, 2022, between GCAPS Property Group LLC and HTG Riverview6, Ltd.
which has a purchase price of $120,000.
ii. First Housing received a Buyer’s and Seller’s Combined Closing Statement, dated
March 28, 2022, between Liberty Rains, LLC and HTG Riverview6, Ltd. which
has a purchase price of $120,000.
Exhibit E
Page 22 of 43
iii. First Housing received a Closing Statement, dated June 23, 2022, between Ernest
S. Marshall and Patricia K. Marshall, individually and as Co-Trustees of the
Revocable Trust Agreement of Ernest S. Marshall & Patricia K. Marshall, dated
June 23, 2016 and HTG Riverview6, Ltd., which has a purchase price of
$1,196,750.
iv. First Housing received a Closing Statement, dated July 28, 2022, between Daniel
G. Anderson and HTG Riverview6, Ltd. which has a purchase price of $190,000.
v. First Housing received a Closing Statement, dated September 7, 2022, between
Richard Lewis West and Heather R. West and HTG Riverview6, Ltd. which has a
purchase price of $400,000.
2. The appraisal, dated October 28, 2022, indicated that the market value “as is”, as of August
2, 2022, is $2,040,000. Therefore, the appraisal supports the total purchase price.
Applicant Costs
Revised
Applicant Costs
Underwriters
Total Costs - CUR
Cost Per Unit
HC Ineligible
Costs - CUR
Debt Servi ce Coverage Reserve (Syndicator)
$0 $253,068 $253,068 $3,163 $253,068
$0 $253,068 $253,068 $3,163 $253,068
RESERVE ACCOUNTS
Total Reserve Accounts:
Notes to Reserve Accounts:
1. An ODR in the estimated amount of $253,068 and is required by the Syndicator. In
exchange for receiving funding from the Corporation, the Corporation reserves the
authority to restrict the disposition of any funds remaining in any operating deficit
reserve(s) after the term of the reserve’s original purpose has terminated or is near
termination. Authorized disposition uses are limited to payments towards any outstanding
loan balances of the Development funded from the Corporation, any outstanding
Corporation fees, any unpaid costs incurred in the completion of the Development (i.e.,
deferred Developer Fee), the Development’s capital replacement reserve account
(provided, however, that any operating deficit reserve funds deposited to the replacement
reserve account will not replace, negate, or otherwise be considered an advance payment
or pre-funding of the Applicant’s obligation to periodically fund the replacement reserve
account), the reimbursement of any loan(s) provided by a partner, member or guarantor as
set forth in the Applicant’s organizational agreement (i.e., operating or limited partnership
agreement whereby its final disposition remains under this same restriction. The actual
direction of the disposition is at the Applicant’s discretion so long as it is an option
permitted by the Corporation. In no event, shall the payment of amounts to the Applicant
or the Developer from any operating deficit reserve established for the Development cause
the Developer Fee or General Contractor fee to exceed the applicable percentage
limitations provided for in this RFA.
Exhibit E
Page 23 of 43
At the end of the Compliance Period, any remaining balance of the ODR less amounts that
may be permitted to be drawn (which includes Deferred Developer Fee and
reimbursements for authorized member/partner and guarantor loan(s) pursuant to the
operating/partnership agreement), will be used to pay FHFC loan debt; if there is no FHFC
loan debt on the proposed Development at the end of the Compliance Period, any remaining
balance shall be used to pay any outstanding FHFC fees. If any balance is remaining in the
ODR after the payments above, the amount should be placed in a Replacement Reserve
account for the Development. In no event shall the payments of amounts to the Applicant
or the Developer from the Reserve Account cause the Developer Fee or General Contractor
Fee to exceed the applicable percentage limitations provided for in Rule Chapter 67-48.
Any and all terms and conditions of the ODR must be acceptable to Florida Housing, its
legal counsel, and its Servicer.
Applicant Costs
Revised
Applicant Costs
Underwriters
Total Costs - CUR
Cost Per Unit
HC Ineligible
Costs - CUR
$22,589,136 $33,800,611 $33,857,873 $423,223 $4,703,398
TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS:
TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
Notes to Total Development Costs:
1. The Total Development Costs has increased by a total of $11,268,737 or 49.89% from
$22,589,136 to $33,857,873 since the Application. The increase is mainly due to the
increase in construction costs.
Exhibit E
Page 24 of 43
Operating Pro FormaRIVERVIEW6
FINANCIAL COSTS:
Year 1
Year 1
Per Unit
OPERATING PRO FORMA
Gross Potential Rental Income $1,005,924 $12,574
O
ther Income
Ancillary Income $84,211 $1,053
Miscellaneous $68,000 $850
Gross Potential Income $1,158,135 $14,477
Less:
Physical Vac. Loss Percentage: 4.00% $46,325 $579
Collection Loss Percentage: 1.00% $11,581 $145
Total Effective Gross Income $1,100,228 $13,753
Fi xed:
Real Estate Taxes $76,000 $950
Insurance $88,000 $1,100
Variable:
Management Fee Percentage: 4.00% $44,009 $550
General and Administrative $36,000 $450
Payroll Expenses $112,000 $1,400
Utilities $36,000 $450
Marketing and Advertising $4,000 $50
Maintenance and Repairs/Pest Control $72,000 $900
Reserve for Replacements $24,000 $300
Total Expenses $492,009 $6,150
Net Operating Income $608,219 $7,603
Debt Service Payments
First Mortgage - Grandbridge/Freddie Mac $537,450 $6,718
Second Mortgage - City of Bradenton $8,050 $101
Third Mortgage - Manatee County $24,500 $306
Fourth Mortgage - Bradenton CRA $0 $0
Total Debt Service Payments $570,000 $7,125
Cash Flow after Debt Service $38,219 $478
FINANCIAL COSTS:
Annual Per Unit
Debt Service Coverage Ratios
DSC - First Mortgage plus Fees 1.13x
DS
C - Second Mortgage plus Fees 1.11x
DSC - Third Mortgage plus Fees 1.07x
Financial Ratios
Operating Expense Ratio 44.72%
Break-even Economic Occupancy Ratio (all debt) 91.90%
INCOME:
EXPENSES:
Please note, the subordinate debt is payable from available cash flow. First Housing has included
the payments for illustrative purposes only.
Exhibit E
Page 25 of 43
Notes to the Operating Pro Forma and Ratios:
1. The rent levels are based on the 2022 maximum LIHTC rents published on FHFC’s website
for Manatee County less the applicable utility allowance. See the chart below.
Manatee County, North Port-Sarasota-Bradenton MSA
1,005,924$
80
66,016
3
2.0
7
1,093
60%
$139
1,432$
1,432$
1,246$
1,246$
1,246$
2
2.0
22
$1,571
1,208$
1,208$
3
2.0
7
1,093
70%
$1,347
$139
1,208$
1,208$
3
2.0
2
1,093
30%
$673
$139
534$
534$
534$
1,432$
120,288$
534$
12,816$
101,472$
1,432$
803
70%
$1,359
$1,165
469$
469$
39,396$
$113
469$
469$
1,052$
239,856$
$113
1,052$
1,052$
1,052$
328,944$
$113
1,246$
2
2.0
19
803
60%
$582
2
2.0
7
803
30%
1,032$
1,032$
1,032$
1,032$
86,688$
62,640$
1
1.0
7
624
70%
$1,134
$102
$102
870$
870$
870$
870$
384$
13,824$
1
1.0
6
624
60%
$972
$486
$102
384$
384$
384$
1
1.0
3
624
30%
High
HOME
Rents
Gross HC
Rent
Bed
Rooms
Bath
Rooms
Units
Square
Feet
AMI%
Low
HOME
Rents
Appraiser
Rents
CU Rents
Annual Rental
Income
Utility
Allow.
Net
Restricted
Rents
PBRA
Contr
Rents
Applicant
Rents
2. The utility allowances are based on an Energy Consumption Model Estimate for electricity
prepared by Matern Professional Engineering, Inc. (“Matern”) and a Manatee County
Utility Allowance Schedule, dated January 1, 2022, for water and sewer. The utility
allowance for electricity was approved by David Hines at Florida Housing on September
6, 2022, for credit underwriting purposes.
3. The appraisal projected a vacancy and collection loss of 3.5%. First Housing utilized a
vacancy and collection loss of 5.0% to be more conservative.
4. The Development will include approximately 3,765 s.f. of commercial space; however, the
Appraisal indicates only 3,198 s.f. Currently no letters of interest are available. The
Appraiser projected commercial income of $80,000, which includes a 5% vacancy loss.
First Housing concluded to $84,211, as a 5% vacancy and collection loss is applied to this
number, resulting in the same retail income of $80,000.
5. The Miscellaneous Income category includes other income from the property including
revenues from administrative fees, washer/dryer, vending machines, and miscellaneous
sources. The Miscellaneous Income is projected at $68,000 or $850/unit/year and
supported by the appraisal.
Exhibit E
Page 26 of 43
6. Based upon operating data from comparable properties, third-party reports (Appraisal and
Market Study) and the Credit Underwriter's independent due diligence, First Housing
represents that, in its professional opinion, estimates for Rental Income, Vacancy, Other
Income, and Operating Expenses fall within a band of reasonableness.
7. The appraisal concluded to an insurance amount of $74,000 or $925/unit. First Housing
concluded to an insurance amount of $88,000 or $1,100/unit to be more conservative.
8. The Applicant has submitted an executed Management Agreement, dated February 9, 2022
between HTG RIVERVIEW6, LTD. (“Owner”) and HTG Management, LLC (“Agent”).
The agreement states the Agent will receive a monthly fee of $2,500 or 4% per month of
gross collections, whichever is greater. The Manager shall be entitled to receive an
additional 2% management fee, subject to available cash low as an incentive management
fee, not to exceed a total management fee of 6%.
9. Residents are responsible for electric and water/sewer expenses. The landlord is
responsible for trash and pest control expenses.
10. Replacement Reserves of $300 per unit per year are required per Rule 67-48. Per an email,
dated October 5, 2022, RJAHI is requiring Replacement Reserves at $300 per unit,
increasing by 3% per year.
11. The Break-even Economic Occupancy Ratio includes all debt; however, the subordinate
debt is payable from available cash flow. This ratio would improve to 89.09% if the
subordinate debt payments were not included in the calculation.
12. Refer to Exhibit 1, Page 1 for a 15-Year Pro Forma, which reflects rental income increasing
at an annual rate of 2%, and expenses increasing at an annual rate of 3%.
Exhibit E
Page 27 of 43
Section B
Housing Credit Allocation Recommendation & Contingencies
Exhibit E
Page 28 of 43
Housing Credit Allocation Recommendation
First Housing Development Corporation has estimated a preliminary annual 9% HC allocation of
$1,699,990 and an annual HC CHRIP allocation of $500,000 for an overall annual HC allocation
of $2,199,990. Please see the HC Allocation Calculation in Exhibit 2 of this report for further
details.
Contingencies
The HC allocation will be contingent upon the receipt and satisfactory review of the following
items by First Housing and Florida Housing by the deadline established in the Preliminary
Determination. Failure to submit these items within this time frame may result in forfeiture of the
HC Allocation.
1. Satisfactory resolution of any outstanding past due or noncompliance issues applicable to
the Development Team prior to closing.
2. This report is subject to Florida Housing’s Asset Management Department’s approval of
the Applicant’s selection of management company.
3. This report is subject to continued approval of the management agent by Florida Housing.
4. The General Contractor shall secure a payment and performance bond equal to 100 percent
of the total construction cost.
5. Receipt of executed FHFC Fair Housing, Section 504, and ADA as built certification forms
122, 127, 129.
6. At least 30% of the Developer Fee must be deferred pursuant to the requirements of the
CHIRP.
7. Any other reasonable requirements of the Servicer, Florida Housing, or its Legal Counsel.
Exhibit E
Page 29 of 43
Section C
Supporting Information & Schedules
Exhibit E
Page 30 of 43
15-Year Pro Forma
FINANCIAL COSTS:
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7 Year 8 Year 9 Year 10 Year 11 Year 12 Year 13 Year 14 Year 15
OPERATING PRO FORMA
Gross Potential Rental Income $1,005,924 $1,026,042 $1,046,
563 $1,067,495 $1,088,844 $1,110,621 $1,132,834 $1,155,490 $1,178,600 $1,202,172 $1,226,216 $1,250,740 $1,275,755 $1,301,270 $1,327,295
Other Income
Ancillary Income $84,211 $85,895 $87,613 $89,365 $91,153 $92,976 $94,835 $96,732 $98,667 $100,640 $102,653 $104,706 $106,800 $108,936 $111,115
Miscellaneous $68,000 $69,360 $70,747 $72,162 $73,605 $75,077 $76,579 $78,111 $79,673 $81,266 $82,892 $84,549 $86,240 $87,965 $89,725
Gross Potential Income $1,158,135 $1,181,298 $1,204,924 $1,229,022 $1,253,603 $1,278,675 $1,304,248 $1,330,333 $1,356,940 $1,384,079 $1,411,760 $1,439,995 $1,468,795 $1,498,171 $1,528,135
Less:
Physical Vac. Loss Percentage: 4.00% $46,325 $47,252 $48,197 $49,161 $50,144 $51,147 $52,170 $53,213 $54,278 $55,363 $56,470 $57,600 $58,752 $59,927 $61,125
Collection Loss Percentage: 1.00% $11,581 $11,813 $12,049 $12,290 $12,536 $12,787 $13,042 $13,303 $13,569 $13,841 $14,118 $14,400 $14,688 $14,982 $15,281
Total Effective Gross Income $1,100,228 $1,122,233 $1,144,677 $1,167,571 $1,190,922 $1,214,741 $1,239,036 $1,263,816 $1,289,093 $1,314,875 $1,341,172 $1,367,996 $1,395,355 $1,423,263 $1,451,728
Fi xe d:
Real Estate Taxes $76,000 $78,280 $80,628 $83,047 $85,539 $88,105 $90,748 $93,470 $96,275 $99,163 $102,138 $105,202 $108,358 $111,609 $114,957
Insurance $88,000 $90,640 $93,359 $96,160 $99,045 $102,016 $105,077 $108,229 $111,476 $114,820 $118,265 $121,813 $125,467 $129,231 $133,108
Variable:
Management Fee Percentage: 4.00% $44,009 $44,889 $45,787 $46,703 $47,637 $48,590 $49,561 $50,553 $51,564 $52,595 $53,647 $54,720 $55,814 $56,931 $58,069
General and Administrative $36,000 $37,080 $38,192 $39,338 $40,518 $41,734 $42,986 $44,275 $45,604 $46,972 $48,381 $49,832 $51,327 $52,867 $54,453
Payroll Expenses $112,000 $115,360 $118,821 $122,385 $126,057 $129,839 $133,734 $137,746 $141,878 $146,135 $150,519 $155,034 $159,685 $164,476 $169,410
Utilities $36,000 $37,080 $38,192 $39,338 $40,518 $41,734 $42,986 $44,275 $45,604 $46,972 $48,381 $49,832 $51,327 $52,867 $54,453
Marketing and Advertising $4,000 $4,120 $4,244 $4,371 $4,502 $4,637 $4,776 $4,919 $5,067 $5,219 $5,376 $5,537 $5,703 $5,874 $6,050
Maintenance and Repairs/Pest Control $72,000 $74,160 $76,385 $78,676 $81,037 $83,468 $85,972 $88,551 $91,207 $93,944 $96,762 $99,665 $102,655 $105,734 $108,906
Reserve for Replacements $24,000 $24,720 $25,462 $26,225 $27,012 $27,823 $28,657 $29,517 $30,402 $31,315 $32,254 $33,222 $34,218 $35,245 $36,302
Total Expenses $492,009 $506,329 $521,070 $536,245 $551,865 $567,944 $584,497 $601,536 $619,077 $637,133 $655,721 $674,857 $694,555 $714,834 $735,709
Net Operating Income $608,219 $615,903 $623,607 $631,326 $639,058 $646,796 $654,539 $662,280 $670,016 $677,741 $685,451 $693,139 $700,800 $708,429 $716,018
Debt Service Payments
First Mortgage - Grandbridge/Freddie Mac $537,450 $537,450 $537,450 $537,450 $537,450 $537,450 $537,450 $537,450 $537,450 $537,450 $537,450 $537,450 $537,450 $537,450 $537,450
Second Mortgage - City of Bradenton $8,050 $8,050 $8,050 $8,050 $8,050 $8,050 $8,050 $8,050 $8,050 $8,050 $8,050 $8,050 $8,050 $8,050 $8,050
Third Mortgage - Manatee County $24,500 $24,500 $24,500 $24,500 $24,500 $24,500 $24,500 $24,500 $24,500 $24,500 $24,500 $24,500 $24,500 $24,500 $24,500
Fourth Mortgage - Bradenton CRA $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Total Debt Service Payments $570,000 $570,000 $570,000 $570,000 $570,000 $570,000 $570,000 $570,000 $570,000 $570,000 $570,000 $570,000 $570,000 $570,000 $570,000
Cash Flow after Debt Service $38,219 $45,904 $53,607 $61,327 $69,058 $76,797 $84,539 $92,281 $100,016 $107,742 $115,451 $123,139 $130,801 $138,429 $146,019
FINANCIAL COSTS:
Annual Annual Annual Annual Annual Annual Annual Annual Annual Annual Annual Annual Annual Annual Annual
Debt Service Coverage Ratios
DSC - First Mortgage plus Fees 1.13 1.15
1.16 1.17 1.19 1.20 1.22 1.23 1.25 1.26 1.28 1.29 1.30 1.32 1.33
DSC - Second Mortgage plus Fees 1.11 1.13 1.14 1.16 1.17 1.19 1.20 1.21 1.23 1.24 1.26 1.27 1.28 1.30 1.31
DSC - Third Mortgage plus Fees 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.15 1.16 1.18 1.19 1.20 1.22 1.23 1.24 1.26
Financial Ratios
Operating Expense Ratio 44.72% 45.12% 45.52% 45.93% 46.34% 46.75% 47.17% 47.60% 48.02% 48.46% 48.89% 49.33% 49.78% 50.22% 50.68%
Break-even Economic Occupancy Ratio (all debt) 91.90% 91.31% 90.75% 90.21% 89.69% 89.19% 88.72% 88.26% 87.83% 87.42% 87.02% 86.65% 86.29% 85.96% 85.64%
INCOME:
EXPENSES:
Please note, the subordinate debt payments are payable from available cash flow but have been show for illustrative purposes. According to an email,
dated October 5, 2022, RJAHI will require replacement reserves at $300 per unit per year, increasing 3% per year.
Exhibit E
Page 31 of 43
HC Allocation Calculation
Section I: Qualified Basis Calculation
Total Development Costs(including land and ineligible Costs)
$33,857,873
Less Land Costs
$2,026,750
Less Federal Grants and Loans
$0
Less Other Ineligible Costs
$2,676,648
Total Eligible Basis
$29,154,475
Applicable Fraction
100%
DDA/QCT Basis Credit
130%
Qualified Basis
$37,900,818
Housing Credit Percentage
9.00%
Annual Housing Credit Allocation
$3,411,074
Notes to the Qualified Basis Calculation:
1. Other ineligible costs include, demolition, retail space, washer/dryers, site work, off-site
construction, accounting fees, FHFC fees, legal, market study, advertising/marketing fees,
title insurance and recoding fees, construction interest, permanent loan costs, and operating
deficit reserves.
2. The Development has a 100% set-aside; therefore, the Applicable Fraction is 100%.
3. For purposes of this analysis, the development is located in a QCT and Geographic Areas
of Opportunity and qualifies as a Local Government Areas of Opportunity; therefore, the
130% basis credit was applied.
4. For purposes of this recommendation a HC percentage of 9% was applied based on the 9%
floor rate which as permanently extended through the Protecting Americans from Tax
Hikes (PATH) Act of 2015 as part of the Omnibus Consolidated Appropriations Act of
2016.
Exhibit E
Page 32 of 43
Section II: GAP Calculation
Total Development Costs(including land and ineligible Costs)
$33,857,873
Less Mortgages
$10,292,000
Less Grants
$0
Equity Gap
$23,565,873
HC Syndication Percentage to Investment Partnership
99.99%
HC Syndication Pricing
$0.93
HC Required to meet Equity Gap
$25,342,183
Annual HC Required
$2,534,218
Notes to the Gap Calculation:
1. The syndication information was taken from LOI, dated September 8, 2022.
2. The committed first mortgage in the amount of $7,132,000 exceeds the minimum first
mortgage requirement of $6,702,139
Section III: Summary
HC Per Applicant's Request
$1,699,990
HC Per Qualified Basis
$3,411,074
HC Per GAP Calculation
$2,534,218
Annual HC Recommended
$2,199,990
Syndication Proceeds based upon Syndication Agreement
$20,457,861
1. The HC Per Application Request is based on the original annual HC request of $1,699,990.
2. The estimated annual housing credit allocation is limited to the lesser of the Qualified Basis
calculation, the GAP calculation or the Applicant's Request. The recommendation is based
on the Applicant’s original Request of $1,699,990 plus the requested HC CHIRP of
$500,000 for a total recommended amount of $2,199,990.
3. FHFC reserves the right to resize the Housing Credit preliminary awarded to the Applicant.
The next opportunity for a feasibility review of this transaction will be at cost certification.
If the cost certification indicates a need to resize the HC allocation, FHFC will do so at that
time.
Exhibit E
Page 33 of 43
Rule Chapter 67-48.0072(28)(g)
Determination of the minimum first mortgage for use in the Housing Credit gap calculation
Input Variables
Annual rate of increase for revenues 2.00%
Annual rate of increase for operating expenses 3.00%
Vacancy & Collection Factor in CUR 5.00%
Minimum Vacancy & Collection Factor 7.00%
Which Rule was applicable at time of Application? Post 7/11/2019
M in imu m DSCR Year 15 1.25x
M in imu m DSCR Year 1 1.50x
Minimum NCF after DS Year 1 $1,000.00
Minimum qualifying 1st mortgage $500,000.00
Number of units in the proposed Development 80
Potential Gross Income Year 1 $1,158,135.00
Vacancy & Collection Loss (7.00%) $81,069.45
Effective Gross Income Year 1 $1,077,065.55
Operating Expenses Year 1 $492,009.13
(i) Actual Debt of Development $7,132,000.00
Actual interest rate 7.09%
Actual term of debt amortization 40.00 Yrs
DS Interest Rate floor 7.00%
Application deadline 11/05/20
10-Year Treasury Rate as of App deadline 0.768%
Spread over 10-yr Treasury 325 bps
10-yr Treasury plus the stated spread 4.02%
Greater of interes t rate floor or spread over Treas ury 7.00%
M aximu m Rate 8.00%
Interest Rate to be used for qualifying debt 7.09%
Minimum stated term of debt amortization per RFA 30.00 Yrs
Term of debt amortization to be us ed for qualifying debt 40.00 Yrs
Resulting Mortgage Constant to be used for qualifying debt 7.53575%
Minimum De bt Se rvice
NOI Year 15 $676,957.17
DSCR DS limitation $541,565.73
(a) Res ulting Debt, Year 15 limitation $7,186,619.96
NOI Year 1 $585,056.42
(b)(i) DSCR DS limitation $390,037.61
(b)(i) DSCR Debt Sizing $5,175,829.88
(b)(ii) NCF DS limitation $505,056.42
(b)(ii) NCF Debt Sizing $6,702,138.51
(b) Greater of (i) DSCR debt or (ii) NCF debt, Year 1 limitation $6,702,138.51
(ii) Minimum qualifying first mortgage (les ser of (a) or (b)) $6,702,138.51
Gre ate r of Actual or M inimum
$7,132,000.00
Exhibit E
Page 34 of 43
Select the RFA of the Active Award 2020-201
Actual DSCR in approved CUR
1st Mtg LOI Number of units 80
Actual DSCR in current
1st Mtg LOI
(Yr 1 NOI)
1.13x Total Development Costs $33,857,873
Maximum CHIRP DSCR 1.30x Active Award Annual HC Allocation 1,699,990.00$
Minimum Per Rule Chapter 67-48.0072(28)(g)2. 1.13x Traditional 1st Mtg Amort. Years 40.00
DSCR used for sizing (lowest DSCs from above) 1.13x Traditional 1st Mtg Interest Rate 7.09%
Actual Traditional 1st Mtg Amount to be stated in CUR
7,132,000.00$ Total Vacancy & Collection Rate in CUR 5.00%
Calculated 1st Mtg at Restricted DSCR (1.13x) 7,132,000.00$ Total Effective Gross Income in CUR Yr 1 1,100,228.25$
1st Mtg Restricted to 1.13x DSCR 7,132,000.00$ Total Operating Expenses in CUR Yr 1 492,009.13$
RESULT: 1st Mtg amount for sizing purposes 7,132,000.00$
Net Operating Income in CUR Yr 1 608,219.12$
Net Operating Income in CUR Yr 15 716,018.50$
1st Mtg amt. for sizing from above 7,132,000.00$ Syndication Rate 0.930000$
2nd Mortgage - City of Bradenton 460,000.00$ Percentage sold to Syndicator 99.990%
3rd Mortgage - Manatee County 1,400,000.00$ Annual HC from LOI or Servicer LOI
4th Mortgage - City of Bradenton CRA 1,300,000.00$ Stated HC Allocation from: LOI 1,699,990.00$
5th Mortgage - -$ Total HC Equity from: LOI 15,808,326.01$
6th Mortgage - -$ Developer Fee % Basis for Deferral (16%) 16%
Total HC Equity 15,808,326.01$ Total 16% Developer Fee $4,355,593
30% Deferred Developr Fee for Sizing 1,306,677.90$
Is the Demographic Commitment either
Homeless or Persons with Special Needs?**
No
Total Sources 27,407,003.91$ Loan using lowest 1.13x DSCR 7,132,000.00$
Total Uses 33,857,873.09$ Loan using Max CHIRP 1.30x DSCR 6,208,550.52$
NOI for 67-48.0072(28)(g)2.a. 676,957.17$
Loan using 67-48.0072(28)(g)2.a. $7,186,619.96
RESULT: Total Gap 6,450,869.18$ NOI for 67-48.0072(28)(g)2.b. 585,056.42$
Associated HC Allocation 693,711.00$ Loan using 67-48.0072(28)(g)2.b.(I) 5,175,829.88$
Loan using 67-48.0072(28)(g)2.b.(II) 6,702,138.51$
Lesser of a. or greater of b.(I) and b.(II) 6,702,138.51$
Greater of Actual 1st or above minimum 7,132,000.00$
Minimum Qualifying 1st Mtg per 67-48 7,132,000.00$
Current GC Contract Amount $20,764,738 Debt Service on 67-48.0072(28)(g)2. 537,449.71$
30% of GC Contract (est. Increased costs)* 6,229,421.40$ DSC Ratio for 67-48.0072(28)(g)2. 1.13x
Increased Corporation Fees -$
Increased Construction Financing Costs -$
Increased Dev. Fee (16.00% x sum of new costs) 996,707.42$ Dev Fee Deduct for Incorporating Actual Fee 0.00%
RESULT: Total Increased Costs 7,226,128.82$
Associated HC Allocation 777,080.00$
*(This amount already meets or exceeds the maximum CHIRP award so there is no need to enter any values in the next two rows.)
Development Name: RIVERVIEW6
Permanent Period 1st Mortgages for Sizing Purposes
Assumptions
Total Sources
FINAL: TOTAL NEW 9% HC ALLOCATION AMOUNT
$2,199,990.00
Test 1 - GAP ANALYSIS
Test 2 - INCREASED COST ANALYSIS
(This amount will be deducted from 16.00%, yielding a net 16.00%)
ADDITIONAL FHFC LOAN AMOUNT
Lessor of: Tests 1 & 2 or $500,000
$500,000.00
Exhibit E
Page 35 of 43
RFA 2020-201
(RIVERVIEW6 / 2021-111C)
DESCRIPTION OF FEATURES AND AMENITIES
The Development will consist of:
80 apartment units located in 1 mid-rise, 5 to 6 story residential building.
Unit Mix:
Sixteen (16) one bedroom/one bath units;
Forty-Eight (48) two bedroom/two bath units; and
Sixteen (16) three bedroom/two bath units.
80 Total Units
All units are expected to meet all requirements as outlined below. If the proposed Development
consists of rehabilitation, the proposed Development’s ability to provide all construction features
will be confirmed as outlined in Exhibit F of the RFA. The quality of the construction features
committed to by the Applicant is subject to approval of the Board of Directors.
a. Federal Requirements and State Building Code Requirements for all Developments
All proposed Developments must meet all federal requirements and state building
code requirements, including the following, incorporating the most recent
amendments, regulations and rules:
Florida Accessibility Code for Building Construction as adopted pursuant to
Section 553.503, Florida Statutes;
The Fair Housing Act as implemented by 24 CFR 100;
Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973*; and
Titles II and III of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 as implemented
by 28 CFR 35.
*All Developments must comply with Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as implemented by 24
CFR Part 8 (“Section 504 and its related regulations”). All Developments must meet accessibility standards of
Section 504. Section 504 accessibility standards require a minimum of 5 percent of the total dwelling units,
but not fewer than one unit, to be accessible for individuals with mobility impairments. An additional 2 percent
of the total units, but not fewer than one unit, must be accessible for persons with hearing or vision impairments.
To the extent that a Development is not otherwise subject to Section 504 and its related regulations, the
Development shall nevertheless comply with Section 504 and its related regulations as requirements of the
Corporation funding program to the same extent as if the Development were subject to Section 504 and its
related regulations in all respects. To that end, all Corporation funding shall be deemed “Federal financial
assistance” within the meaning of that term as used in Section 504 and its related regulations for all
Developments.
Exhibit E
Page 36 of 43
b. General Features
The Development will provide the following General Features:
1. Termite prevention;
2. Pest control;
3. Window covering for each window and glass door inside each unit;
4. Cable or satellite TV hook-up in each unit and, if the Development offers cable or
satellite TV service to the residents, the price cannot exceed the market rate for
service of similar quality available to the Development’s residents from a primary
provider of cable or satellite TV;
5. Washer and dryer hook ups in each of the Development’s units or an on-site laundry
facility for resident use. If the proposed Development will have an on-site laundry
facility, the following requirements must be met:
o There must be a minimum of one Energy Star certified washer and one
Energy Star certified or commercial dryer per every 15 units. To determine
the required number of washers and dryers for the on-site laundry facility;
divide the total number of the Development’s units by 15, and then round
the equation’s total up to the nearest whole number;
o At least one washing machine and one dryer shall be front loading that
meets the accessibility standards of Section 504;
o If the proposed Development consists of Scattered Sites, the laundry facility
shall be located on each of the Scattered Sites, or no more than 1/16 mile
from the Scattered Site with the most units, or a combination of both.
At least two full bathrooms in all 3 bedroom or larger new construction units;
Bathtub with shower in at least one bathroom in at least 90 percent of the new
construction non-Elderly units;
Elderly Developments must have a minimum of one elevator per residential
building provided for all Elderly Set-Aside Units that are located on a floor higher
than the first floor; and
Full-size range and oven must be provided in all units.
c. Required Accessibility Features, regardless of the age of the Development
Federal and state law and building code regulations requires that programs, activities, and
facilities be readily accessible to and usable by persons with disabilities. Florida Housing
requires that the design, construction, or alteration of its financed Developments be in
compliance with federal and state accessibility requirements. When more than one law and
accessibility standard applies, the Applicant shall comply with the standard (2010 ADA
Standards, Section 504, Fair Housing Act, or Florida Building Code, Accessibility) which
affords the greater level of accessibility for the residents and visitors. Areas required to be
made accessible to mobility-impaired residents and their visitors, including those in
wheelchairs, shall include, but not be limited to, accessible routes and entrances, paths of
Exhibit E
Page 37 of 43
travel, primary function areas, parking, trash bins, mail and package receiving areas for
residents, pool and other amenities, including paths of travel to amenities and laundry
rooms, including washers and dryers.
(1) Required Accessibility Features in all Units
Primary entrance doors on an accessible route shall have a threshold with no
more than a ½-inch rise;
All door handles on primary entrance door and interior doors must have lever
handles;
Lever handles on all bathroom faucets and kitchen sink faucets;
Mid-point on light switches and thermostats shall not be more than 48 inches
above finished floor level; and
Cabinet drawer handles and cabinet door handles in bathroom and kitchen shall
be lever or D-pull type that operate easily using a single closed fist.
(2) In addition to the 5 percent mobility requirement outlined above, all Family
Demographic Developments must provide reinforced walls for future installation
of horizontal grab bars in place around each tub/shower and toilet, or a Corporation-
approved alternative approach for grab bar installation. The installation of the grab
bars must meet or exceed the 2010 ADA Standards for Accessible Design.
At the request of and at no charge to a resident household, the Development shall
purchase and install grab bars around each tub/shower unit and toilet in the dwelling
unit. The product specifications and installation must meet or exceed 2010 ADA
Standards for Accessible Design. The Development shall inform a prospective
resident that the Development, upon a resident household’s request and at no charge
to the household, will install grab bars around a dwelling unit’s tub/shower unit and
toilet, pursuant to the 2010 ADA Standards. At a minimum, the Development shall
inform each prospective lessee by including language in the Development’s written
materials listing and describing the unit’s features, as well as including the language
in each household’s lease.
d. Required Green Building Features in all Developments
(1) All units must have the features listed below:
Low or No-VOC paint for all interior walls (Low-VOC means 50 grams per
liter or less for flat; 150 grams per liter or less for non-flat paint);
Low-flow water fixtures in bathroomsWaterSense labeled products or the
following specifications:
o Toilets: 1.28 gallons/flush or less,
o Urinals: 0.5 gallons/flush,
o Lavatory Faucets: 1.5 gallons/minute or less at 60 psi flow rate,
o Showerheads: 2.0 gallons/minute or less at 80 psi flow rate;
Energy Star certified refrigerator;
Exhibit E
Page 38 of 43
Energy Star certified dishwasher;
Energy Star certified ventilation fan in all bathrooms;
Water heater minimum efficiency specifications:
o Residential Electric:
Up to 55 gallons = 0.95 EF or 0.92 UEF; or
More than 55 gallons = Energy Star certified; or
Tankless = 0.97 EF and Max GPM of 2.5 over a 77◦ rise or 0.87 UEF
and GPM of ≥ 2.9 over a 67◦ rise;
o Residential Gas (storage or tankless/instantaneous): Energy Star certified,
o Commercial Gas Water Heater: Energy Star certified;
Energy Star certified ceiling fans with lighting fixtures in bedrooms;
Air Conditioning (in-unit or commercial):
o Air-Source Heat Pumps Energy Star certified:
≥ 8.5 HSPF/ ≥15 SEER/ ≥12.5 EER for split systems
8.2 HSPF ≥15 SEER/ ≥12 EER for single package equipment including
gas/electric package units
o Central Air Conditioners – Energy Star certified:
≥15 SEER/ ≥12.5 EER* for split systems
≥15 SEER/ ≥12 EER* for single package equipment including gas/electric
package units.
NOTE: Window air conditioners and portable air conditioners are not allowed.
Package Terminal Air Conditioners (PTACs) / Package Terminal Heat Pumps
(PTHPs) are allowed in studio and 1 bedroom units.
(2) In addition to the required Green Building features outlined in (1) above, this New
Construction Development commits to achieve the following Green Building
Certification program:
_______ Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED);
_______ Florida Green Building Coalition (FGBC);
_______ Enterprise Building Communities; or
___X___ ICC 700 National Green Building Standard (NGBS).
e. This Family Development will provide the following resident programs:
(1) Adult Literacy
The Applicant or its Management Company must make available, at no cost to the
resident, literacy tutor(s) who will provide weekly literacy lessons to residents in
private space on-site. Various literacy programming can be offered that strengthens
participants’ reading, writing skills, and comprehension, but at a minimum, these
must include English proficiency and basic reading education.
Exhibit E
Page 39 of 43
Training must be held between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 7:00 p.m. and electronic
media, if used, must be used in conjunction with live instruction. If the
Development consists of Scattered Sites, this resident program must be provided
on the Scattered Site with the most units.
(2) Employment Assistance Program
The Applicant or its Management Company must provide, at no cost to the resident,
a minimum of quarterly scheduled Employment Assistance Program
workshops/meetings offering employment counseling by a knowledgeable
employment counselor. Such a program includes employability skills workshops
providing instruction in the basic skills necessary for getting, keeping, and doing
well in a job. The instruction must be held between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 7:00
p.m. and include, but not be limited to, the following:
Evaluation of current job skills;
Assistance in setting job goals;
Assistance in development of and regular review/update of an individualized
plan for each participating resident;
Resume assistance;
Interview preparation; and
Placement and follow-up services.
If the training is not provided on-site, transportation at no cost to the resident must
be provided. Electronic media, if used, must be used in conjunction with live
instruction.
(3) Financial Management Program
The Applicant or its Management Company shall provide a series of classes to
provide residents training in various aspects of personal financial management.
Classes must be held at least quarterly, consisting of at least two hours of training
per quarter, and must be conducted by parties that are qualified to provide training
regarding the respective topic area. If the Development consists of Scattered Sites,
the Resident Program must be held on the Scattered Site with the most units.
Residents residing at the other sites of a Scattered Site Development must be
offered transportation, at no cost to them, to the classes. The topic areas must
include, but not be limited to:
Financial budgeting and bill-paying including training in the use of
technologies and web-based applications;
Tax preparation including do’s and don’ts, common tips, and how and where to
file, including electronically;
Fraud prevention including how to prevent credit card and banking fraud,
identity theft, computer hacking and avoiding common consumer scams;
Exhibit E
Page 40 of 43
Retirement planning & savings options including preparing a will and estate
planning; and
Homebuyer education including how to prepare to buy a home, and how to
access to first-time homebuyer programs in the county in which the
development is located.
Different topic areas must be selected for each session, and no topic area may be
repeated consecutively.
Exhibit E
Page 41 of 43
DEVELOPMENT
NAME: RIVERVIEW6
DATE: October 31, 2022
In accordance with the applicable Program Rule(s), the applicant is required to submit the information required to evaluate,
complete, and determine its sufficiency in satisfying the requirements for Credit Underwriting to the Credit Underwriter in
accordance with the schedule established by the Florida Housing Finance Corporation ("FHFC"). The following items must be
satisfactorily addressed. "Satisfactorily" means that the Credit Underwriter has received assurances from third parties unrelated
to the applicant that the transaction can close within the allowed time frame. Unsatisfactory items, if any, are noted below in the
"Issues and Concerns" section of the Executive Summary.
FINAL REVIEW
REQUIRED ITEMS:
STATUS NOTE
Satis. / Unsatis.
1. The development’s final “as submitted for permitting” plans and specifications.
Note: Final “signed, sealed, and approved for construction” plans and specifications will be
required thirty days before closing.
Satis.
2. Final site plan and/or status of site plan approval. Satis.
3. Permit Status. Satis.
4. Pre-construction analysis (“PCA”).
a. No construction costs exceeding 20% is subcontracted to any one entity with the
exception of a subcontractor contracted to deliver the building shell of a building of at
least 5 stories which may not have more than 31% of the construction cost in a
subcontract.
b. No construction costs is subcontracted to any entity that has common ownership or
is an affiliate of the general contractor of the developer.
Satis.
Satis.
Satis.
5. Survey. Satis.
6. Complete, thorough soil test reports. Satis
7. Full or self-contained appraisal as defined by the Uniform Standards of Professional
Appraisal Practice.
Satis.
8. Market Study separate from the Appraisal. Satis.
9. Environmental Site Assessment Phase I and/or the Phase II if applicable (If Phase I
and/or II disclosed environmental problems requiring remediation, a plan, including
time frame and cost, for the remediation is required). If the report is not dated within
one year of the application date, an
update from the assessor must be provided
indicating the current environmental status.
Satis.
10. Audited financial statements for the most recent fiscal year ended or acceptable
alternative as stated in Rule for credit enhancers, applicant, general partner, principals,
guarantors and general contractor.
Satis.
11. Resumes and experience of applicant, general contractor and management agent.
Confirmed active status on Sunbiz for Applicant, Developer, and GC entities.
Satis.
12. Credit authorizations; verifications of deposits and mortgage loans. Satis.
13. Management Agreement and Management Plan. Satis.
14. Firm commitment from the credit enhancer or private placement purchaser, if any. N/A
Exhibit E
Page 42 of 43
15. Firm commitment letter from the syndicator, if any. Satis. 1.
16. Firm commitment letter(s) for any other financing sources. Satis. 2.
17. Updated sources and uses of funds. Satis.
18. Draft construction draw schedule showing sources of funds during each month of the
construction and lease-up period.
N/A
19. Fifteen-year income, expense, and occupancy projection. Satis.
20. Executed general construction contract with "not to exceed" costs. Satis.
21. HC ONLY: 15% of the total equity to be provided prior to or simultaneously with the
closing of the construction financing.
Satis.
22. Any additional items required by the credit underwriter. Satis.
23. Receipt of executed Florida Housing Fair Housing, Section 504 and ADA Design
Certification Forms 121, 126, and 128.
Satis.
24. If the owner has a HAP Contract or ACC with HUD, then receipt of HUD approval
for an owner-adopted preference or limited preference specifically for individuals or
families who are referred by a designated Referral Agency serving the county where
the Development is located.
N/A
25. Receipt of Tenant Eligibility and Selection Plan Satis.
26. Receipt of GC Certification Satis.
27. Reliance for FHDC as agent for FHFC is include in all applicable third party reports:
Appraisal, Market Study, PCA, CNA, and Phase I.
Satis.
1. An Amended and Restated Limited Partnership Agreement is not available, First Housing
utilized the letter, dated September 8, 2022, within this report.
2. Receipt of a firm commitment from Fifth Third Bank (construction), Grandbridge/Freddie Mac
(permanent), and for the subordinate debt are not available, First Housing is relying on the term
sheets provided.
Exhibit E
Page 43 of 43